Resident Evil 3 Remake: Hit or Miss? (A Comprehensive Deep Dive)

The 2020 release of Resident Evil 3 Remake (RE3R) by Capcom was met with both excitement and scrutiny. Building on the success of the Resident Evil 2 Remake, RE3R sought to modernize another classic in the franchise while paying homage to its original 1999 counterpart. This article will examine RE3R in depth, analyzing its gameplay mechanics, story, graphics, and reception to understand what makes it stand out and where it fell short.

A Revamped Raccoon City

One of RE3R’s highlights is its portrayal of Raccoon City, a sprawling urban environment teetering on the brink of collapse due to the T-Virus outbreak. Unlike the claustrophobic halls of the Raccoon City Police Department in Resident Evil 2, RE3R opens up the city, allowing players to traverse rooftops, alleyways, and neon-lit streets. This environment exudes chaos, with burning vehicles, panicked citizens, and hordes of zombies.

However, one criticism often leveled at the game is the limited exploration of Raccoon City. While the environments are detailed and immersive, the campaign’s linear progression contrasts with the interconnected design of Resident Evil 2’s map. The potential for deeper urban exploration was hinted at but not fully realized.

Jill Valentine: A Modern Heroine

Jill Valentine’s characterization is one of the game’s strongest aspects. Played by Nicole Tompkins, Jill is portrayed as a seasoned survivor grappling with the horrors unleashed by Umbrella Corporation. Her sharp wit and resilience make her a compelling protagonist. The updated character design trades the tactical mini-skirt for a more practical outfit, reflecting a modern sensibility while retaining her iconic identity.

Jill’s journey is supported by Carlos Oliveira, a member of the Umbrella Biohazard Countermeasure Service (UBCS). Carlos’ expanded role and dynamic interplay with Jill add depth to the story, though some fans argued that his playable sections occasionally disrupted the pacing.

Nemesis: The Pursuer

The titular Nemesis, a bioengineered weapon designed to eliminate S.T.A.R.S. members, is both an asset and a flaw of RE3R. Nemesis’ relentless pursuit in the original game was a defining feature, but in the remake, his scripted appearances diminished the tension. While his boss encounters are intense, they lack the unpredictability and improvisation that defined Mr. X in Resident Evil 2.

That said, Nemesis’s design is terrifying. His grotesque transformations and imposing presence keep players on edge, even if his AI behavior feels overly constrained. The flamethrower and rocket launcher he wields during set pieces add variety to the gameplay but sometimes shift the tone toward action over horror.

Gameplay: Survival Meets Action

RE3R’s gameplay is a blend of survival horror and action. Players must manage limited resources, solve puzzles, and fend off relentless enemies. The dodge mechanic, a returning feature from the original, adds a layer of skill-based evasion. Perfectly timed dodges slow down time, allowing for precise counterattacks. This mechanic enhances the game’s pace and provides players with tools to survive against overwhelming odds.

Weapon variety is another highlight, with everything from handguns to grenade launchers at Jill’s disposal. Upgradable weapons encourage exploration and strategic thinking, as players decide which tools to prioritize for encounters with powerful foes.

Despite these strengths, RE3R leans heavily into action, often at the expense of its horror roots. Some sequences feel like corridor shooters, with waves of enemies and explosive set pieces dominating over atmospheric dread. While thrilling, this tonal shift alienated fans who expected a more traditional survival horror experience.

Graphics and Sound Design

Capcom’s RE Engine once again demonstrates its prowess in RE3R. The visuals are stunning, with detailed character models, realistic lighting, and atmospheric environments. Raccoon City’s streets teem with life (and death), creating an immersive sense of dread. Gore effects are particularly visceral, with dismemberment and decayed enemies adding to the horror.

The sound design complements the visuals, from the unsettling moans of zombies to the thunderous roar of Nemesis. The soundtrack mixes reimagined themes from the original with new compositions, though some fans missed the haunting melodies that defined the 1999 version. Voice acting, particularly Jill and Carlos’s performances, enhances the emotional weight of the story.

The Campaign: Short and Sweet

One of the most significant criticisms of RE3R is its campaign length. Clocking in at around 6-8 hours on a first playthrough, the game’s brevity left many players wanting more. The omission of iconic locations, such as the Clock Tower, and the absence of branching paths reduced replayability compared to the original.

That said, the streamlined campaign has its merits. It delivers a tightly paced narrative that keeps players engaged from start to finish. Hardcore and Nightmare difficulty modes provide additional challenges for those seeking replay value, though they do not compensate for the trimmed content.

Resistance: The Multiplayer Experiment

To bolster the value of RE3R, Capcom included Resident Evil Resistance, an asymmetrical multiplayer mode. Resistance pits four survivors against a mastermind who controls traps, zombies, and other obstacles. While an interesting concept, Resistance struggled to gain a dedicated player base and lacked the polish of the main game. Its inclusion felt like an afterthought rather than a meaningful addition to the package.

Reception and Legacy

Resident Evil 3 Remake received generally favorable reviews, with critics praising its visuals, gameplay, and character development. However, it faced criticism for its short campaign, reduced content, and reliance on action over horror. Fans of the original were particularly vocal about the missing elements that defined their nostalgia.

Despite these shortcomings, RE3R’s quality is undeniable. It succeeds in modernizing a beloved classic, even if it falls short of the benchmark set by Resident Evil 2 Remake. For newcomers, it serves as an accessible entry point into the series, while veterans can appreciate the updated mechanics and visuals.

Conclusion: A Worthy but Imperfect Remake

Resident Evil 3 Remake is a game of contrasts. It shines as a technical showcase and an engaging action-horror experience but falters in delivering the depth and replayability of its predecessor. For fans of the series, it is a worthwhile journey back to Raccoon City, though not without its caveats.

As Capcom continues to revisit its classics, RE3R stands as a reminder of the challenges of balancing nostalgia with innovation. While not a perfect remake, it reinforces the enduring appeal of Resident Evil and leaves the door open for future reinterpretations of its storied history.

---

Sources:

• Capcom’s official website and developer interviews

• Resident Evil 3 (1999) and Resident Evil 3 Remake (2020) gameplay comparisons

• Critical reviews from IGN, GameSpot, and Metacritic